I find the Fist of Guthix rewards, particularly for melee, quite disappointing. Berserker shield seems somewhat pathetic in the effort required to earn 300 tokens OSRS Power Leveling, and 35 to recharge every 5-6 hour. It provides one more protection in each area than the kite counterpart. If you have a number (ex. You may be able to do 1 more damage for every digit you have (ex. Even with 1 extra damage, this reward is pretty insignificant considering how often it has to be recharged.
Rune gauntlets are nice, but again there's the recharge cost if you die, and if you pk (which is pretty much the only use for them in F2P) you'll surely die and that's a hassle.
Even the reward for range of the green d'hide hat is feeble for how often it requires recharge. The best class for rewards is mage because they offer the best rewards, even when not charged. I think the charges need to be longer lasting or completely eliminated to increase the initial cost. It's a pain to have to return to the farm to collect more tokens every five or six hours and pay Reggie to recharge. What do you feel?
What a disappointment! I was expecting these things to be revolutionary for events, and yet again a loosening rules of how events are run. These things should allow Forge-level customization with dialog boxes and saveable configurations. This is a real tool. So that's what I was expecting. While some might have issues with the release to the RS community Buy OSRS Fire Cape, I wanted something more substantial.